I rate it ... fair!
2.0/5.0
See my post about book reviews for details about my review criteria and biases.
I'm always concerned when I put up a less-than-stellar review of any product. I'm well aware of the time and energy that goes into a creating a book, being an author myself. But if one can't post an honest review of one's opinion, then what is the point of a review? As always, this is only my opinion, and that of others may differ widely.
This is a relatively short (48 page) quilling book that introduces the art of quilling to beginners, and provides a few easy projects for them to try. It ends with a gallery of those same projects done by children.
What I liked:
The book has nice, bright color images of projects. My copy came with a small package of paper strips on the inside back cover, so a few projects could be tried immediately.
What liked less:
The tutorial for beginners is much too short, and misses out on some important techniques such as making roses. Some potential resources and supplies are not mentioned that are standard in other books, such as fringers, molds and such. The overall quality of the quilling in the projects is not high, showing uneven tension and very large open centers. The projects themselves are not terribly interesting, and I don't think they will inspire children or adults to try the craft. There is no history section, and the gallery space could have been used better with a few more advanced projects, rather than showing children's work.
Overall, as a collector, I felt compelled to buy it. But for a beginner, there are much better quilling books on the market.
No comments:
Post a Comment