I rate it … very good!
4.4/5.0
See my post about book reviews for details about my review criteria and biases.
If I had an adult friend who was interested in learning quilling, this is probably the book I would get for them. This book almost has it all, and what it does have is nicely photographed, well detailed and a pleasure to use. I don't think I'd use it for a young person (projects are more functional rather than just fun), but I think the book is well suited for an adult.
What I liked:
This book is laid out a little differently than others, focusing on beginners and their questions. Each section (such as Section 2, The Basics) is motivated by subheadings in the form of questions (such as How do I make a folded rose?). This lends a relaxed feel to the book that I think would appeal to a beginner. The quality of the quilling is very good throughout the book. The tutorial shows examples of good and poor quilling, and what can cause problems. All the necessary techniques are illustrated, and then some. Pictures are plentiful, and instructions are clear.
What I liked less:
I really missed a history section, but you know my bias there - I just think a beginner's book needs some history. I thought the projects got a little too difficult too quickly, but this is a minor point. The projects were not as appealing to me as some other books, but given I'm not a beginner, the book isn't targeted to me. I thought some of the projects needed more detailed line drawings of the actual patterns. The gallery of projects at the back is nice, but I wanted more. (I always do :)
Overall, I'd recommend this book for an adult beginner. As a collector I'm glad to have it on my shelf, and there are a few tidbits here and there that help spark the imagination even of a seasoned quiller.
No comments:
Post a Comment